Home            Artist links            Label link

Album cover

Edhels - Universal

Artist: Edhels
Title: Universal
Label: Mals MALS 053
Length(s): 44 minutes
Year(s) of release: 2005
Month of review: [01/2006]

Line up

Marc Ceccotti - guitar
Jean-Luis Suzzoni - guitar
Yannick Chavatier - drums, percussion
Lionel Routier - bass
Jean-Marc Bastianelli - vocals, keyboards, percussion
Paul Mayan - bass on the live tracks
Sandrine Bonnet - backing vocal

Tracks

1) Martha 3.12
2) No Message/Sophie's Legs 8.15
3) Tenera Lupa 5.22 MP3
4) Mad Wedding 7.16
5) Egyptian's Matter 5.30
6) Keep In Contact 3.50
7) Martha (live) 10.57

Summary

Edhels is a band which has existed for some time releasing a string of refined instrumental on Musea. This is a vocal album released on the Russian Mals label.

The music

Martha is a stop and start tune, with a bit of of a funky feel and but including Frippian guitar playing (Discipline era). The song never really gets going, the singing is quite bad (both the accent and the sloppy technique). The music also sounds very unproduced. When I first heard it, I thought it was a live album, but in view of the fact that the last song has (live) makes me think differently.

Still, a song like No Message/Sophie's Legs sounds so very live that I can hardly think otherwise. The guitar sound reminds me somewhat of the blues rock oriented sound of Rick Ray. The sound quality is not great here. The vocals are still quite sloppy and uncontrolled, but the first part at least has a memorable vocal melody. Halfway we switch into Sophie's Legs, which is more in the vein of plain blues rock with female backing vocals. In between the guitar sound is varied enough, with a Genesis feel pervading this second part, alternated with Frippian excursions. An interesting combo.

Tenera Lupa continues this album which has a bit more groove than usual in the prog world. Especially on this track, Bastianelli sings with feeling, set against a very atmospheric background. In a song like this it seems his way of singing pays off, the freedom he takes is used well.

On Mad Wedding, the funkiness rises high again, this is certainly not the Edhels I remember. For a funk band, I guess Edhels lack the precision (you can be groovy and precise) in this context. In between, we have het Frippian excursions lead, I would think, by Ceccotti. But maybe the two guitarists have split up the Frippian leads and the blues rock leads. The song has quite some dreamy passages, in which I recall Genesis. But past halfway, we get an experimental break after which we move into avant areas (The ProjeKCts).

Egyptian's Matter is a very Discipline/Belew like track, the vocalist scatting over the place. His vocals style is also similar to Belew. The follow-up track is similarly styled, Keep In Contact. The vocalist repetitively lets us hear that we wants to keep contact. It sounds a bit manic. The song does have some darker vocal passages as well. But the vocals and lyrics are still not great, which certainly hampers the song.

We end with a long live version of Martha, the opener of the track. This is an atmospheric opening track with subtle guitar play, and percussive piano. The free vocal style fits the song well this time, and he also seems to perform somewhat better in a live situation. The voice of the vocalist, but the way, reminds me of the vocalist of Castanarc. Halfway the angular Frippian guitars set in, but we get plodding bluesrock instead, a bit in the vein of Rick Ray. This final half is more like the opener version.

Conclusion

In a way Edhels can be compared to Minimum Vital. They have gone from instrumental to vocal now and they try to cross over into a different kind of music than sympho/prog. A big difference is that the feel of Minimum Vital stays symphonic, and they have two really excellent singers. On Universal Edhels sounds more like a rock band which is investigating more varied song structures, and includes references to Genesis, but mainly Fripp and consorts. A large part of the variation comes from the use of two guitars playing different styles. Problematic are the vocals and the sound quality. Neither are great, making the album sound very live (although only the last song is marked as such). If you liked Edhels before, take a listen first: the band has changed quite a bit, and not for the better.

© Jurriaan Hage