Home            Artist links            Label link

Album cover

Pineapple Thief - Variations On A Dream

Artist: Pineapple Thief
Title: Variations On A Dream
Label: Cyclops CYCL 129
Length(s): 63 minutes
Year(s) of release: 2003
Month of review: [01/2004]

Line up

Bruce Soord - guitars, vocals, keyboards, samples, programming
Adrian Soord - mellotron, fender rhodes, prophet 5, piano, synths
Nick Lang - drums, percussion, backing vocals
Mark Harris - bass

Tracks

1) We Subside 4.58
2) This Will Remain Unspoken 3.27
3) Vapour Trails 8.31
4) Run Me Through 4.41 MP3
5) The Bitter Pill 4.36
6) Resident Alien 4.14
7) Sooner Or Later 4.16
8) Part Zero 7.27
9) Keep Dreaming 4.26
10) Remember Us 16.18

Summary

Their second album was an excellent surprise, following the guiding lights of Porcupine Tree among others, and adding a few twists of their own. Quite soon after, before the next Vulgar Unicorn in fact, the band returns with another one. There is even a double cd version of this one out, including a second album called 99 Days, but I do not have it.

The music

Ah well, what can I say? This is certainly one for my top ten over the year 2003 (in fact, I did actually put it in). The main references I can find are a mix between No-Man and Porcupine Tree. We Subside for instance opens with dreamy, melodic vocals, an excellent vocal melody. There is also something of Thom Yorke in the vocal twists. Pineapple Thief are not great experimenters as Radiohead currently are making them a good replacement for those who did not want to keep up.

This Will Remain Unspoken continues the downer line of the music. This is not music to get happy by. The strumming acoustic guitar, the nice subdued orchestration and the somewhat desperate vocals all add to this effect.

With Vapour Trails we finally arrive at something of progressive length (harumph). Bleepy keys, slow moving, soft voiced vocals, this is a dreamy one. This continues for over four minutes, after which we come to the instrumental section, which continues in laid back fashion, after which the melancholic repetitive chorus sets in. The final few minutes are even more dreamy.

Run Me Through for some reasons reminds me of Abacab in the opening. The continuation is quite different, i.e., in the line of the previous. There is a bit more pace in the song now, but we stay on the progressive pop side. The guitar solo is a strong one.

The Bitter Pill is a light strumming affair, somewhat faceless by comparison to the wonderful Resident Alien. The opening reminds me of Oldfields Tubular Bells, with lots of interplaying effects. No vocals on this one.

Sooner Or Later has plenty of tension, with the addition of rhythmic guitar and some nice psyche lines. The vocal melody of the chorus is again a great one. This is also one of the rowdier tracks with sharp guitar work and a bit of power and drive. The pop sensibility is not gone though.

Part Zero is among the tracks, one of the lenghier ones. Again the presence of strumming acoustic guitars and this time also some moody synth cello. Very somber. Great vocal melodies again, this time the vocal parts are quite up-beat. Mellotronic moods pervade this track as well and we have some Anekdoten like eruptions to deal with as well.

Keep Dreaming has a bit of a Gazpacho feel, slow and percussive. This is also something of a moving children song in the chorus, but the main reference is still Radiohead, but friendlier. Nice mellotron and oboe like synths sound us out. The rhythm side of it all is loose and modern.

Remember Us is the epic track running more than sixteen minutes. What can you expect here? The same as before, but with lots of low underneath the friendly melodic acoustic guitar. Later the pace sets in somewhat as we move up to mid-tempo. The guitar sounds rather psychedelic here. The doubled vocals sound quite poppy. Notwithstanding its length a song which easily wurms itself a way into your mind. At times the music can be quite sharp almost hallucinogenic with a string reverb. Halfway we come to a part where the guitar simply grind out the noise, but then the song gets underway again with repetitive guitar plus keyboard patterns, building things up nicely indeed.

Conclusion

Why do Coldplay and Radiohead get all their attention and Pineapple Thief does not? Money? Luck? I guess all of those and maybe more, but certainly not a lack in quality and not even originality because the identity of Pineapple Thief is firm and hardly to be mistaken for any other band. Expecting the world to be just is naive though and I guess Pineapple Thief will have to stay where they are: making records for Cyclops and not getting noticed.

This album continues a number of rounded well-penned, played, sung etc. compositions which leave little to be desired. Except maybe that the music and the vocalist should fire up a bit more in places, to counter the slow and dreamy overall tone somewhat. Pineapple Thief should appeal to Placebo, Porcupine Tree and No-Man listeners, as well as Coldplay and Radiohead, with their special brand of progressively arranged pop songs.

© Jurriaan Hage