P r o S u p p o r t
Case 9: Tent ownership
Statements
Evidence
Issues
Discussion
Decisions
Claim disputation
Disputed claim
Disputation
Maker
--
Plaintiff
Defendant
Judge
Source
--
Statement of Claim
Defence
Reply
Rejoinder
Intermediate verdict
(other: ...)
Grounds
elaborate
more grounds
alternative grounds
Adversary's response
--
Disputed
Conceded
Deferred to the judge
Not responded
elaborate
Judge's response
- Procedural:
--
Admissible
Not admissible
elaborate
- Burden of proof:
--
Plaintiff
Defendant
elaborate
- Substantial:
--
Comparison
Rejection
elaborate
Remarks
The judge rejects plaintiff's attack on the credibility of defendants main witness. Note that the judge does not explicitly respond to plaintiff's subclaim that van de Velde has stated something that would be demonstrably false.